The Walking Dead - Four Walls and a Roof Review (Season 5, Episode 3)
(Spoilers)
If I had to choose one word to describe this episode of The Walking Dead, that word would be: shocking.
We're only three episodes into the season, and so far many plot points that I expected to happen in the mid-season finale have already happened. Escaping Terminus in episode 1 of the season, that was a surprise. But killing off Bob! This early into the season? Didn't expect that. But, by far, the biggest shock was killing off the man I was sure would become the season long antagonist, the next Governor even! The Walking Dead killed off Gareth in episode 3 of the Season. Damn. Didn't expect that.
So yes, "Four Walls and a Roof" centered around this conflict with the Terminus survivors and the big result was these two deaths. They both were shocking, but only one of them I liked.
The one that I did like, was Gareth's. It was brutal, unexpected, and it had an awesome buildup, with them walking into the church, acting all macho, then being quickly captured by Rick. And Rick's awesome pre-murder one liner? It was great. Rick did indeed keep his promise to kill Gareth with his machete. What the next threat of the season will be, who knows?
Now, about that other death, Bob's. I really liked Bob, so maybe I'm biased on this. Why kill Bob this early? I've been waiting for him to get some actual good story lines, besides the few he got in Season 4, his debut season. I've liked him just because of his standard personality, and the fact that the actor portraying him played one of my favorite characters on The Wire, so I was really hoping he could become one of the biggest, bestest, most developed characters on the show. Instead they kill him, before he has the chance to be the next member of the important circle of characters like Rick, Glenn, Maggie, Carl, Daryl, and Carol. Those people are basically safe from all danger for now. Shame Bob left so soon.
Now that all the big death discussions are out of the way, let's talk about the other great stuff in this episode.
The opening was fantastic, and by fantastic, I mean super awesome, my favorite scene of the Season thus far. Tainted Meat will live on as Bob's greatest moment. Incredible acting in that scene too. I really felt Bob's satisfaction in telling those Terminus cannibals that they, in fact, have eaten tainted meat. It felt so great to see the smirks being wiped off their faces.
Other important stuff in this episode was the feud between Rick and Abraham. It led to a splitting up of the group again. While Abraham and Rick pretty much made up, Abraham has decided to take Eugene and the rest of his people to Washington, before Rick and his group are ready. I sure hope they meet up again soon.
The last few minutes of this episode where meditative and quiet, after the sheer brutality of Gareth and the gang's death. I felt these scenes were necessary to the episode, and it was a nice way to close out the episode.
The very, very end of the episode was an abrupt cliffhanger (Daryl walking out of the woods, Carol not in sight) and I can't wait to see how it all plays out in the coming episodes (Next weeks episode is Beth-centric, and I hope it's good, because it looks very intriguing.)
+Fast paced
+Shocking death of Gareth and his people
+Rick being more of a badass (new Shane?)
+Cliffhanger
-Bob's death comes too early in the series
Score: 9/10